On Sunday, guest speaker, Bruce Johnson (wiredtogrow.com), taught at the Mid-Atlantic Community Church (aka, The MACC themacc.org). The message/sermon is posted here: http://themacc.org/uploads/112011_1100.mp3. It sets out to be the standard tithing sermon, which, were that achieved, I would simply be letting out a heavy sigh and moving on. However, there are statements within this particular message that deviate too far outside a simple heavy sigh response.
Bruce is introduced by the Senior and Founding Pastor, Lew Schrumm. Lew speaks very highly of Bruce’s accomplishments and of their relationship. Bruce started a church plant with just a couple of families and it grew to 2000 members. He became a church planting coach for a period of time, where Lew and he met. Bruce left ministry and became a business consultant helping businesses become more profitable. Lew points out that Bruce has been his personal mentor/coach for the past 18 months. All this to say, Bruce is presented as an authority, which is fine and good, as long as he wields great authority with great humility.
To help clarify my position, I am objecting to some key points within the content of this message, nothing more. I do not know Bruce. However, some of his (hopefully off-script) comments vacillate between overtly-persuasive, hyperbolic sales-pitches and just plain wrong.
Additionally, I have been a member of the MACC for seven years. The good news for all people is preached and lived here. Usually the guest speakers bless the community. If you came into worship afflicted and left even more so, know that is in no way representative of the last 7 years.
We are in this together. We are not in competition.
At 2:00, immediately after the introduction, Bruce’s opening remarks:
“I started with all those young guys by the way [Lew and several other church planting pastors] and you guys and Lew have schmoked all of them! You’re church has done phenomenally well of the past 6, 7 years. So, good news for you.”
I hear this all the time {heavy sigh}. Normally my heavy sigh is enough and no more is needed. However, Bruce’s opening remark sets a sales-pitch tone that never dissipates. A church plant is not in competition with other church plants or, for that matter, any other churches. Never has been. Never should will be. Because if we are, we are no longer the church. I think this competitive spirit is a business consultant’s sales-pitch showing. Businesses compete because there is only so much revenue to be gained. However, within the church there is grace enough for all. And then some.
Again, this content objection alone is not much more that a annoying nit — It could not stand on its own. Unfortunately, it does not have to…
Financial giving is a sacrifice not an investment.
At 7:27, we get one full minute of the prosperity gospel. There really is no other way to describe it. The zinger at the end of the minute (again, possible attempt at off-script humor/sales) seals this deal.
“The third reason you don’t need to be afraid is because the bible clearly links God’s blessing to giving! So why should you ever be afraid to hear a message of more of God’s blessings. I mean, I don’t know about you, but I need some more. Right?”
So far, well, okay. If Bruce would continue on by carefully define the many possible ways God might bless us, it would be okay and I’d be simply letting out my heavy sigh. Sadly, he zooms in on only one possible blessing: $$$. This singular misconception has led to the birth of the prosperity gospel churches. Televangelists have popularized this misconception to the point of absurd self-parodies. I think American capitalism seduces the church into buying this “investment/lets make a deal” Christianity.
We could easily cut-n-paste the beatitudes or Job or Moses or Paul or Jesus himself to illustrate the many non-financial blessings that may come. Suffice it to say, if more giving translates to more financial blessings, Mother Theresa (who gave roughly 89% more than 10%) should have died the wealthiest person in history, next to Jesus, of course, who gave all. Yet both of them, and many others, died living in abject poverty.
Jesus states that those who follow him will have suffering in this world. Paul counts himself blessed to suffer for Christ’s sake. The blessing one might receive may very well be suffering, which is pretty far away from financial blessings.
This “how to cash in on God” is the carrot. The stick is reserved for minute 35:00. God smiting the financially unfaithful may be found there. Then 3 or 4 examples at the end supporting these claims. Sad and scary. Buying God’s blessings. If it were as simplistically formulaic as implied here, we would never need another sales pitch/sermon on this topic. Yet, there are several millionaire non-Christians and millions of impoverished, devoted followers of Christ. The empirical data over the past few thousand years does not support this formula. And, if we study it in its entirety, neither does the Bible.
Tithing to a church is most definitely NOT a God-Love barometer with which we may judge each other.
Whatever anyone wants to believe with respect to tithing is fine with me. If you believe the 10% tithe applies in the new covenant and want to give that and more to your local church, do so. If you believe tithes were the temple tax that died with Christ, that fine too. And any belief in between is cool. I’m fine with pretty much anything on your tithe belief because I place tithing in the non-essential area of our faith. However, once someone places this in the essential elements of our faith, we have a problem. Bruce does this, in the harshest of possible terms, at around 17:00 minutes into his sermon pitch.
“When I was pastoring, I used to know how much everyone in our church gave. And so people would come up and they’d say, ‘Hey, I love God!’ And I’d be sitting there thinking, ‘No you don’t! Because I know you make over a 100 grand a year, and last year you gave $300! That’s less than 6 bucks a week. You spend more on coffee each week… than you give to God. Don’t tell me you love God because it’s not true!”
If you feel the surrounding context helps to soften the blow of these words, maybe you gave more than $300 last year. Or maybe you make only 99 grand. Or maybe you were not listening. These words are wrong on at least two levels. Nothing softens the blow of these harsh, judgmental words. These words have no place in the mouth or heart of any Christian.
So the rich people present who give very little just got called out. You don’t love God. You’re lying. You’re a fake. A phoney. Christ obviously is not in you. Which really, is not that much of a stretch since that is what those words actually mean! And the not so rich got a little reprieve… they may still love God even though they put damn little in the church offering plates. Although, they too spent more on coffee last week. So yeah, you don’t love God either I guess. Sucks for you, eh?
Based on two pieces of data, Bruce passes an extremely harsh judgement. Judgement is (obviously, I hope) the second level of wrong. Here we see our senior pastor’s pastor, his mentor and coach, modeling an extremely harsh judgmental attitude towards brothers and sisters! He makes no apology at all for thinking these thoughts. He shares these sinful thoughts as though they represent a good, sound sermon illustration. He’s actually sounds proud. Everyone listening (hopefully most were tuned out by this point) immediately wondered if Bruce’s student, their very own pastor, has been, silently and hypocritically, passing the same harsh judgment upon them week after week.
It is most certainly is not okay for a pastor, Christian, or any respectful human being, to pass harsh judgments based on two numbers. Or 70 even. To which, God’s people say, “Well, duh!?”
I need some more.
At this point, a mere 18 minutes into a 52 minute message, this sermon is completely off the track. I cannot say how the messenger traveled so far off track. Bruce is, no doubt, very good at selling ideas to business people. He may be a very good teaching pastor on all other topics. For now (as I do not have anywhere near enough information from which to draw any judgement), I am assuming his zeal for pitching persuasive sales gets the better of him. You are welcome to listen to the remaining 34 minutes. However, I would strongly recommend against any serious study based on this message.
“I need some more.” Bruce says this early on and I found myself repeating these words in my head as I left. There are many better messages, delivered with reverence and humility, on the topic of giving. A very good message, like Jesus himself, comforts the afflicted and afflicts the comfortable. This message achieves the exact opposite: comforting the comfortable and afflicting the afflicted.
Filed under: aaarrrrgggghhh!! | Tagged: giving, tithing | 2 Comments »